Fix My Japanese

Share this post

Your high school 部活

plz.fixmyjp.com

Your high school 部活

Sep 12, 2022
Share this post

Your high school 部活

plz.fixmyjp.com

Hi again. Niko here.

This week’s prompt

You’re the new person at work. Your senpai just asked what sort of extracurricular activities you did back in high school.

* You can submit a response in Japanese here. *

Please try to submit your response within 48 hours of receiving this email. Please only write one response per form submission.

Corrections will arrive in your inbox next week.

Last week’s corrections

You’re chatting with the new guy at work. You want to ask him what sort of extracurricular activities he did back in high school.

These culture-heavy situations tend to throw me off a lot, as it’s so tempting to start wondering “Extracurricular activity? What is that even called in Japanese? How does the system for this even work in Japan?”

And if you don’t know that system, well, it seems kind of difficult to have a conversation about it.

Anyway, for this one I might have said:

高校んとき部活かなんかやってた?
こうこう ん とき ぶかつ か なんか やってた?
Were you in any clubs or anything in high school?

Well, what I originally came up with was this sentence minus the かなんか part, and that would have been fine, too. But then Rei suggested adding かなんか, which I thought was a nice touch, as it sounds less direct, much like the nuance added by that “or anything” in English.

I intentionally wrote ん instead of の since during the last few years, I’ve been trying to remind myself to say んとき instead of のとき to make my casual speech sound more like that of a native speaker. When writing, it would be more common to put の, however.

(On a side note, translating 部活 (ぶかつ) as “club activities” or whatever always irks me because 部活 includes sports, but you have sports “teams”, not “clubs” where I went to high school.)

Here is Satoko with everyone’s feedback:

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Fix My Japanese to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2023 NativShark Inc
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing